‘As Received’ vs ‘Dry Basis’: How to Read a Shisha Charcoal Certificate of Analysis

A shisha charcoal certificate of analysis (COA) reports moisture, ash, volatile matter and fixed carbon, and every figure only means something once you know its reporting basis: “as received” includes the moisture in the charcoal as it was sampled, while “dry basis” removes all moisture mathematically, so the same charcoal always looks better on a dry basis. Glowing Charcoal Indonesia (PT Bara Coco Agronesia) holds Sucofindo Certificate of Analysis No. E01021/COBHAT, dated 2 March 2026, for its coconut shell shisha briquettes. On an as-received basis it reports 4.46% total moisture, 2.00% ash, 9.43% volatile matter and 84.11% fixed carbon, and the same report shows 88.04% fixed carbon on a dry basis, which is why suppliers must always be compared on the same basis.
This guide is for private-label brand owners, distributors and QC staff who receive lab reports from several factories and need to compare them fairly. We use our own certificate as a worked example and go through it line by line. If you want our overview of why we test with an independent laboratory, see premium shisha charcoal backed by verified laboratory results. This article is the practical how-to that goes with it.
What Is a Certificate of Analysis for Shisha Charcoal?
A certificate of analysis is a signed report from a laboratory or inspection company that states what was sampled, when and where it was sampled, which tests were run, which methods were used and what the results were. For coconut shell shisha charcoal, the core of most COAs is the proximate analysis: moisture, ash, volatile matter and fixed carbon. Charcoal labs usually borrow these methods from the coal and coke standards. ASTM D3172, the standard practice for proximate analysis of coal and coke, covers the determination of moisture, volatile matter and ash and the calculation of fixed carbon (ASTM D3172). In other words, fixed carbon is not measured directly; it is what is left once the other three have been subtracted.
A COA is evidence about the sample that was tested. It is not a promise about every carton, and it doesn’t cover how a cube lights, how long it lasts on your bowl or how well it survives a sea voyage. Those you check yourself (see our guide on how to test shisha charcoal samples).
What Do “As Received”, “Air-Dried”, “Dry” and “Dry Ash-Free” Mean?
Laboratories report the same result on different bases depending on how much water (and sometimes ash) is counted in the total. ASTM D3180 is the standard practice for calculating coal and coke analyses from the as-determined value to other bases, such as as received, dry and dry ash-free (ASTM D3180). The testing company ALS describes the common bases as follows (ALS, coal basis conversion):
| Basis | Usual abbreviation | What it includes | What it tells a buyer |
|---|---|---|---|
| As received | ar | The total moisture of the sample, i.e. the as-shipped state | Closest to the charcoal you actually pay for and burn |
| Air-dried | ad or adb | The moisture of the lab’s analysis sample once it has come into equilibrium with the humidity of the laboratory air | The basis on which the lab actually ran most tests |
| Dry | d or db | No moisture at all (calculated) | Good for comparing charcoal from humid and dry climates |
| Dry ash-free | daf or dafb | No moisture and no ash (calculated) | Describes only the combustible part; ash is zero by definition |
The key point: removing water or ash from the total makes every other figure bigger. Fixed carbon on a dry ash-free basis will always look higher than fixed carbon as received, even though it is the same charcoal. ALS puts it plainly: when comparing results, compare them on the same basis.
How Do You Read a Shisha Charcoal COA Line by Line?
Here is the results table of our Sucofindo certificate No. E01021/COBHAT exactly as printed, with the method shown for each line. The consignment is described as “coconut charcoal briquette for shisha”; Sucofindo staff took the samples at our factory in Jepara, Central Java, on 2 February 2026, and the certificate was issued on 2 March 2026.
| Parameter | ar | adb | db | dafb | Method printed on the COA |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total moisture (%) | 4.46 | – | – | – | ASTM D3302/D3302M-19 |
| Inherent moisture (%) | – | 6.37 | – | – | ASTM D3173-17a |
| Ash content (%) | 2.00 | 1.96 | 2.09 | – | ASTM D3174-18 |
| Volatile matter (%) | 9.43 | 9.24 | 9.87 | 10.08 | ASTM D3175-20 |
| Fixed carbon (%) | 84.11 | 82.43 | 88.04 | 89.92 | ASTM D3172-(2021)e1 |
Read it in this order:
- Check who, what, when and where. Note the certificate number, issue date, issuing office, the consignment description, the shipper’s name and the date and place of sampling. Our COA also states that the sample was taken from cartons, composited and divided into three parts: one for the laboratory, one kept as a reference for three months and one handed to us.
- Find the basis columns. Here they are ar, adb, db and dafb. If a supplier’s report has only one column and doesn’t say which basis it uses, ask before you compare anything.
- Read total moisture first. Total moisture (4.46%) appears only in the as-received column, because it describes the charcoal as sampled. ASTM D3173 notes that total moisture is used to calculate the other results to an as-received basis (ASTM D3173).
- Don’t confuse inherent moisture with total moisture. The 6.37% is the moisture of the finely prepared analysis sample on the air-dried basis, not the moisture of the cubes in your carton. On this certificate the analysis sample held more water than the as-received cubes, which is why the as-received ash (2.00%) is slightly higher than the air-dried ash (1.96%). That is normal arithmetic, not an error.
- Read ash, volatile matter and fixed carbon down one column. As received, our briquettes show 2.00% ash, 9.43% volatile matter and 84.11% fixed carbon.
- Check that each column adds up to 100. As received: 4.46 + 2.00 + 9.43 + 84.11 = 100.00. Air-dried: 6.37 + 1.96 + 9.24 + 82.43 = 100.00. Dry: 2.09 + 9.87 + 88.04 = 100.00. Dry ash-free: 10.08 + 89.92 = 100.00. If a report’s columns don’t add up, ask why.
- Note what is not on the certificate. This COA has no calorific value, density, cube size, burn time or breakage figures. If you need those, they come from a separate test or from the factory’s own specification, and you should know which is which.
Why Does the Same Charcoal Show Different Fixed Carbon Figures?
Because the water and ash are taken out of the denominator. Using only the figures printed on our certificate, the fixed carbon of one and the same sample reads 84.11% as received, 82.43% air-dried, 88.04% dry and 89.92% dry ash-free. That is a spread of almost 7.5 percentage points without any change in the charcoal.
This matters when a supplier quotes “fixed carbon 88%” without a basis. That figure could match our 84.11% as received, or it could describe a quite different product. Read our article on why the highest carbon content isn’t always the best for the performance side of the question; the point here is simply that a number with no basis can’t be compared.
How Do You Convert a COA from As Received to Dry Basis?
The conversion factors are published in ASTM D3180 and are reproduced in plain form by ALS. For any result other than moisture itself, you multiply by a ratio of “100 minus moisture” terms:
| From | To | Multiply the result by |
|---|---|---|
| As received | Dry | 100 ÷ (100 − total moisture) |
| Air-dried | Dry | 100 ÷ (100 − air-dried moisture) |
| Air-dried | As received | (100 − total moisture) ÷ (100 − air-dried moisture) |
| Dry | Dry ash-free | 100 ÷ (100 − dry ash) |
As a check (our own calculation, not part of the certificate), apply the first row to our as-received figures. The factor is 100 ÷ (100 − 4.46) = 1.0467. Ash: 2.00 × 1.0467 = 2.09%. Volatile matter: 9.43 × 1.0467 = 9.87%. Fixed carbon: 84.11 × 1.0467 = 88.04%. All three match the dry-basis column Sucofindo printed, which shows the report is internally consistent.
You can do the same with another supplier’s numbers. Suppose (a hypothetical example) a report gives ash of 2.1% on a dry basis and total moisture of 6% as received. To put that ash on an as-received basis, multiply by (100 − 6) ÷ 100 = 0.94, which gives about 1.97%. Only now can you set it next to a figure like our 2.00% as received.
Which Figures Matter Most When You Compare Suppliers?
For shisha charcoal, buyers usually focus on three numbers, and each tells you something different:
- Ash: the mineral residue left after burning. Lower ash means less residue on the bowl and in the heat management device. Our guide to ash content in coconut charcoal explains what the percentages mean in a session.
- Moisture: water adds weight but no heat, and very damp charcoal is harder to light. See what moisture level is right for charcoal.
- Volatile matter and fixed carbon: they show how completely the shell was carbonised. Read them together, never fixed carbon alone.
Our Diamond grade is specified at 1.6–2% ash, moisture under 6% and a calorific value of about 8,000 kcal/kg, made from 100% coconut shell. The calorific value is our product specification; it is not one of the results printed on the Sucofindo COA above. The same COA serves as the quality certificate for both our Diamond and Premium (Super Premium) grades.
What Questions Should You Ask a Supplier About Their COA?
- Which basis is each figure on: as received, air-dried, dry or dry ash-free?
- Who took the sample, where and when: the lab’s own staff at the factory, or a sample sent in by the factory?
- Which product and grade does the certificate cover, and does it apply to the grade you are buying?
- Which test methods were used, and do all the columns add up to 100?
- How old is the certificate, and will a new one be issued for your production or shipment if you ask for it?
- Which figures in the quotation come from the lab report and which come from the factory’s own specification?
If you arrange your own third-party inspection, give the inspector the basis you want results reported on, so the new report lines up with the specification in your contract. Our article on documents required when importing charcoal from Indonesia covers the rest of the paperwork.
What Does a COA Not Tell You?
| Question you have | Answered by the COA? | Where to look instead |
|---|---|---|
| Moisture, ash, volatile matter, fixed carbon of the sample | Yes | The results table |
| Calorific value (kcal/kg) | Only if the lab tested it | A separate calorific value test or the factory specification |
| Lighting time, burn time, smell, ash colour on your bowl | No | Your own sample test |
| Cube size, pieces per kg, breakage in transit | No | Your written specification and inspection |
| How the cargo is classified for sea transport | No | Transport documents and the MSDS |
On the transport side, our shisha charcoal is shipped as UN 1361, Class 4.2 dangerous goods under HS code 4402.20.10, and the MSDS is provided with the shipment. We also hold a separate Sucofindo Self Heating Test, No. E01003/COBHAT, dated 2 March 2026. For the background, see what UN 1361 means for a coconut charcoal factory.
How Does This Fit into Ordering from Glowing Charcoal Indonesia?
Glowing Charcoal Indonesia has made 100% coconut shell charcoal since 2016, with a capacity of about 8–10 tons per day. Once your sample and specification are agreed, the terms are:
- Minimum order: 18 tons per 20ft container (one product type per 20ft); a 40ft container can carry two types at 13 tons each.
- Lead time: 28–35 days from receipt of the deposit and approval of your artwork.
- Payment: 50% deposit with the balance 5 days before container loading by T/T, or an irrevocable L/C at sight.
- Shipping: FOB Semarang, Jakarta (Tanjung Priok) or Surabaya depending on vessel availability, and we can handle shipment until the container reaches your port of discharge.
For private-label projects, our OEM and private label page explains how we work with brand owners.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between as received and dry basis on a charcoal COA?
An as-received figure includes all the moisture the charcoal held when it was sampled, while a dry-basis figure is calculated as if all moisture had been removed, so dry-basis ash, volatile matter and fixed carbon are always higher than the as-received figures for the same charcoal.
What does Glowing Charcoal Indonesia’s Sucofindo COA show?
Sucofindo Certificate of Analysis No. E01021/COBHAT, dated 2 March 2026, reports 4.46% total moisture, 2.00% ash, 9.43% volatile matter and 84.11% fixed carbon as received for Glowing Charcoal Indonesia’s coconut charcoal briquettes for shisha.
Is fixed carbon measured directly in a lab test?
Fixed carbon is normally calculated rather than measured, because ASTM D3172 defines the proximate analysis as the determination of moisture, volatile matter and ash and the calculation of fixed carbon from them.
How do I convert as-received results to dry basis?
To convert an as-received result to dry basis you multiply it by 100 divided by (100 minus the total moisture), so with 4.46% total moisture an as-received fixed carbon of 84.11% becomes 88.04% on a dry basis.
Why should I compare shisha charcoal COAs on the same basis?
You should compare COAs on the same basis because the same charcoal can show fixed carbon anywhere from about 82% to 90% depending on whether moisture and ash are counted, so figures on different bases make one product look better than another for no real reason.
Does the COA cover both Diamond and Premium grades?
Yes, Glowing Charcoal Indonesia uses Sucofindo COA No. E01021/COBHAT as the quality certificate for both its Diamond and Premium (Super Premium) shisha charcoal grades.
Can I get a free sample to test alongside the COA?
Yes, Glowing Charcoal Indonesia sends shisha charcoal samples free of charge, and the buyer only pays the courier cost by bank transfer to our company account.
Request a Quote or Free Sample
Comparing lab reports from several factories? Send us your target specification, the basis your contract uses, your expected volume and your destination port, and we will prepare a quote and walk you through our certificate figures on the same basis as your other offers. You can also browse our coconut charcoal briquettes for shisha.
Samples are free; you only pay the courier cost by bank transfer to our company account. Email info@glowingcharcoal.com or WhatsApp +62 812-8400-6660 to request a quote or a free sample.